gww>Wikichu: ArenaNet namespace closed. [bot]

2009-10-07T16:35:10Z

ArenaNet namespace closed. [bot]

New page

{{ArenaNet namespace notice|skill feedback}}
{{skill icon|Smite}}

==  Energy cost too high -- 14:54, 29 August 2008 (UTC) ==
[[ArenaNet talk:Skill feedback/Monk/Smite#|Discussion]]
; Issue
: Energy cost too high. Worse than [[Bane Signet]] but for the recharge.
; Suggestion
: Decrease cost to 5{{energy}} or something.

== Agreed ==

;Issue
:Spear of Light does more damage for less energy and the only downsides are the recharge and it can miss.

;Suggestion
:Decrease cost to 5 and recharge to 10. People have a choice between smite and spear of light. Damage or reliability.

== [[User:Lancy1214|Lancy1214]]'s & [[User:Falconeye|Falconeye]]'s Proposal ==
[[ArenaNet talk:Skill feedback/Monk/Smite#Falconeye's issue|Discussion]]
* '''Issue''': See Above ^_^
::'''See [[Glowing Gaze]]'''
::'''See [[Shock Arrow]]'''
::'''See [[Glowstone]]'''
::'''See [[Glowing Ice]]'''
* '''Suggestion''':
:Please give [[Smite]], [[Essence Strike]], [[Bitter Chill]], & [[Angorodon's Gaze]] the same treatment Anet did with 4 elemental energy-management spells by tying them to thier respective '''Primary Attributes'''... a reliable alternative source of energy-management.
:The change to the 4 elemental e-skills was quite eligent and clever:
:'''1)''' It removed possibility of secondary-abuse.
:'''2)''' It provided free conditional spell regardless of attribute spread.
:'''3)''' Grants superior e-management then old version for each attribute point spent.
:''As of today, evenly split 10/9/9/9/9 elementalist has an option of 4 (+5/1/8) vs. a 16/13's option of 1 (+5/1/8)!''
* '''Proposal''':
:*{{Skill icon|Smite}} - {{skill data|5|1|8}} - (Smiting Prayers) - [[Spell]]. "[[Target]] [[foe]] is struck for {{gr|15|60}} [[holy damage]]. If target is [[knocked down]], you gain 5 [[Energy]] plus 1 Energy for every 2 ranks of [[Divine Favor]]."
'''-=OR=-'''
:*{{Skill icon|Smite}} - {{skill data|5|1|8}} - (Smiting Prayers) - [[Spell]]. "[[Target]] [[foe]] is struck for {{gr|15|60}} [[holy damage]]. if target is [[hex]]ed with Smiting Prayers skill, you gain 5 [[Energy]] plus 1 Energy for every 2 ranks of [[Divine Favor]]."
'''-=OR=-'''
:*{{Skill icon|Smite}} - {{skill data|5|1|8}} - (Smiting Prayers) - [[Spell]]. "[[Target]] [[foe]] is struck for {{gr|15|60}} [[holy damage]]. If target is [[attack]]ing, you gain 5 [[Energy]] plus 1 Energy for every 2 ranks of [[Divine Favor]]."
* '''Reason''':
:The best Monks always have at least '''Divine Favor 10'''. This allows them to mix-in some offence/energy in additon supporting allies, regardless if they are running any combination of '''Healing''', '''Protection''', or '''Smiting'''.
:Makes the '''Primary Attribute''' more essential while reducing the stale/static nature of Monkness (some of us want to smite & heal at same time).
* '''Also See''':
:[[ArenaNet:Skill feedback/Ritualist/Essence Strike|Essence Strike]], [[ArenaNet:Skill feedback/Necromancer/Bitter Chill|Bitter Chill]], & [[ArenaNet talk:Skill feedback/Necromancer/Angorodon's Gaze|Angorodon's Gaze]]
--[[User:Falconeye|Falconeye]] 06:45, 7 November 2008 (UTC)
::Agreed.. Especially on Angorodon's ^^ --[[User:Chaos Messenger|Chaos Messenger]] 15:42, 21 December 2008 (UTC)

== [[User:Bathory|Bathory]]'s Issue 07:44, 10 April 2009 (UTC) ==
[[User_talk:Bathory/Suggestions/Monk#Smite|Comments & Suggestions Here, Please]]
;Issue
:Like above, this would be much more useful as an energy management skill. The only difference I really care about it that the energy gain shouldn't be tied to Divine Favor. To my knowledge, that was done to the Elemental skills to avoid Me/E "FC (insert Element). Forcing every profession to use their Primary attribute in order to gain energy is a bit too intense for most skills and professions to me. So again - my suggestion is similar but different in the ties to Primary Attribute.
;Suggestion
:{{skill data|5|1|8}}
:'''Spell.''' Deals {{gr|10|55}} holy damage. You gain {{gr|1|10}} Energy if target foe is knocked down.

ArenaNet:Skill feedback/Monk/Smite - Revision history

gww>Wikichu: ArenaNet namespace closed. [bot]